Galleries are unusual. They tend to deny the existence of the outside world, keeping it out through the lack of windows and a steady unifying stream of white light, which exempts themselves from ordinary rules of functional use. Yet they are still the dominant place to experience art, despite being far less passive than they appear.
Not so with Space Banana. For five years it has nestled within the building of Birmingham Voluntary Service Counsel (BVSC), its unorthodox space wearing its heart on its sleeve. Essentially an atrium space between meeting rooms (though some projects have delved further into the fabric of the building), it’s distinctiveness as a space used mainly by anotherorganisation sets it apart from any other dedicated contemporary art venue in Birmingham and quite possibly the UK. By being thoroughly unlike a generic gallery space it has forced a debate about the role of audience and artist in many of the shows.
Like many artist run ventures, it started as a place to show work in a city lacking in opportunities for emerging artists and graduates who were all too easily leaving the city after college. Soon after its formation in 1999 by Mary Butler, Steve Aylin, and Jo Capper (three MA fine art students from UCE who replied to an advert that appeared on the college notice board), it successfully received funding to pay modest sums to participating artists. This was largely thanks to Jo Capper and Margaret Anderton, the team that would run the space for the best part of 4 years, through inviting artists to show and selecting from a regular advert in A-N magazine.
Many shows have acknowledged the physicality of the space, but remained firmly on the side of art in a gallery setting. Oversized dresses, castle topped mountains on helium balloons, and a huge pixelated plastic sheet in front of the natural light of the huge windows have appeared besides the work squeezed onto walls or fitted around the furniture.
However, in its five-year tenure at the BVSC, it is Space Banana’s relationship with the host space and the audience that has always been the tricky issue. Set up to help minority groups, the BVSC has a remit for socially inclusive activities, and its initial interest in having art to show in its building was tempered by a desire for community based work. The reality has been that the exhibitions have reflected little of these original hopes, instead providing a vital platform for artists to exhibit and experiment with their practice. At worst however, the artwork has been perplexing wallpaper for the clients using the building during the day.
The plain fact is that with the exception of Birmingham’s relatively small contemporary art audience, the exhibitions hijack their viewers. Yet in this demanding space that leaves little room for art, which just hangs on walls, the strategy of grabbing unsuspecting attention from conference attendees in a coffee break is a valid one. Amongst the blue and green-carpeted atrium, the exposed structure design and the metal railings, you were always reminded of the offices in the building. Consequently the art had to find a way of dealing with that, something that became increasingly important as the exhibitions progressed.
In 2002 and 2003 residencies from a number of artists developed in relation to the ‘space’ of the gallery and its host organisation. This was a significant step towards supporting artists in a more realistic way than just the opportunity to put on a show – it gave them time to develop and work with an idea. Here Space Banana’s programme began to incorporate theBVSC’s daily use as a meeting place for conferences and talks as central to the space and the role of art within it.
Artists began make work that actively used the structures within the buildings. Anthony Housman unearthed and referenced the idea of the ‘gallery’ itself, using marks made on the walls from previous shows; Anthony Place used the shredded information and paper work that are the basis of communication in the building. Tom and Simon Bloor keyed their show into the philanthropic nature of the organisations based in the building, creating a kind of modernist pageantry using quotes and images from Birmingham’s past figures of humanitarianism and libertarianism.
Perhaps the most explicit example of investigation into the gallery as part of the fabric of the BVSC was in Karin Kihlberg’s project Free Lunch. Here the artist took employees of the organisation out to lunch, documenting the resulting conversation. Though the chat was as likely to be about the filling of a baguette as about art, engaging the BVSC’s varied employees in conversation as an open ended process not only exposes the fundamental issues around the use of the space – ideas of value, and who has control of the work shown there and who that work is directed at.
Five years in from its tentative launch, Space Banana occupies a unique position in the Birmingham art scene. Importantly, it represents the only artist-led space in the city where emerging artists, from the city and further a field, get paid for showing work, and where graduates fresh out of college can get shown. It helps artists develop new work and it gets complete autonomy in a space hosted by an organisation that also offers delicious snacks and drinks for the Previews.
Its strengths are in those qualities that mark it out as different, and its independence and unique parasitical position inside another building with somebody else’s audience make it an interesting proposition for any artist.